The Japanese rightist

Tuesday, January 24, 2006

Whitewashing history ? ---- truth of alleged Nanjing massacre

Let's see how Japanese get rightish.
It is known that Nanjing (Nanking) massacre was caused in 1937 with 200,000-300,000 victims in Nanjing by Japanese imperial military. But do you know that it has still been seriously discussed in Japan? These days, there published increasing number of books claiming that Chinese communism party made up most of the pics to make the incident to look brutal.

Those books seem to come up recently. Up until ten years ago, rarely did I see those books. Only did I see some books, which are written in Japanese, describing just how tragic Nanjing massacre was. Most of the books simply investigated brutality of the Japanese crime.

I ran a search in amazon.co.jp for the books published about Nanjing massacre, finding 176 kinds of copies obtainable online. It's an enormous number.






Surprisingly, only one book out of best sold 10 books considers it positive about the existence, while the rest of 9 are likely to be negative or trivializing it. One of the nine is even titled , "We investigated Iris Chang's book and found the manipulation of information by Chinese communism." (More search on 30 copies revealed that: 5 copies favor the claim by Chinese communists and the other 25 copies cast doubt about it.)

*Don't judge me. Don't judge people. Don't prohibit discussion.*
May be Chinese communism made up pics. May be not. I don't know. But we'll keep an eye on whether Japanese people just want to whitewash the history. Anyway, what I can say about it is that Japan is a democratic country. Let them publish whatever they want, and they'll know what should be believed. Whichever the Japanese conclusion is going to be, I'll respect the general opinions after open discussions rather than the conclusion by a dictated country. There's a scholar who strongly protests Chinese claims and you'll see his book later on in this article. I searched web pages with his name, and what I found at the top in google was a critic site, written in Japanese, about his methodology. Criticism exist everywhere even against revisionists. Japanese ultra-rightwingers are of course subject to being under inspection.

Just as Japan, China must give citizens the right of speech and make them dispute. Otherwise, people lose chance to correct their wrong idea. They were taught that Chinese communism made Japan surrender. Huh? Not China. America did! And the people still believe that. (Recently I got news about CCP admit to accepting the fact, though.) How can they know if they can't access some webpages because of strict censorship.

The big difference is the freedom of speech. Notice that those rightists in Japan finally emerged after 50-year open discussion!





I've got the controversial book!


Look what I got! This is the best seller in Japan on the Nanjing's investigation. Since I'm living far from Japan, I ordered one copy from amazon. The book examines 143 pictures that are supposed to be the evidence of Nanjing Massacre, and explains how those pics are made up by Chinese Communists. The title says "Analyzing the photographic evidence of Nanking massacre."

I'll spend several weeks to read and introduce some of them to you.
I already read some of this, and found it interesting, although I don't think all of his claims are acceptable.

The main point I want to emphasize in this section is the gap of emotions between American and Japanese. Look at the picture below.

This pic was taken just after Nanjing was captured by Japan in Dec. 24th 1937. Tokyo Asahi Newspaper highly publicized the victory of Japan with this pic in which kids are flocking to pick up sweets from Japanese military. The author sets out his investigation of pics with this "TRUE" pic, saying "why would they come out and pick up? Weren't they too intimidated to do it by brutal Japanese military?"


Another pic above is from Dec.17th, so several days after fall of Nanjing. The civilains look very happy together with Japanese soldiers. How can it be possible? I thought that this is totally propaganda from Japanese side. They may have hided dark side of Nanjing and propagated exclusively those superfacial joyous scenes. However, I came to another fact after investigation that Japanese troops were well acquainted with how Kuomintang (Chinese) had been snooping aroud to propagate Japan's brutality. The picture was taken to let the world acknowledge that Japan behaved well. Believe it or not, it was information war taken place already 70 years ago!


I refrain from stating what Japan really did in Nanjing in 1937, but let me tell you something. These are the pics Japanese people saw in 1937, believing that Japanese troops behaved well. On the other hand, Americans saw whole other pics from LIFE with brutal scenes possibly caused by Japan. I think this is what we have to regret very much: looking at history in such different ways. Wars are created that way.

Here's a link to my second article on Nanjing: (2)


9 Comments:

At 2/03/2006 05:25:00 PM , Anonymous J-girl said...

南京事件の証拠写真と言われるものが、実は通州事件の写真であったり、新聞に別の見出しで載せられたものの使いまわしだったり、演出を凝らして作成されたものであったりするわけですが、私たちを修正主義と呼ぶ人たちは『アポロの月面着陸だって嘘だと言う人がいるさ』と嘯くのです。
立証の確かさが全然違うと思うのですが・・・???
事実を認めたくないのは一体どっちなの?と言いたくなります。

 
At 2/03/2006 05:29:00 PM , Anonymous J-girl said...

あの・・・。私のコメントが不適切だったり、攻撃的過ぎたりすると判断されたら、遠慮無く削除してください。

 
At 2/03/2006 06:55:00 PM , Blogger yellowpeep said...

日本語だし、いいんじゃないでしょうか。
この問題については、かなり慎重に事を進めて記事を書いていかねばならないと思います。東中野教授は詰めが甘いです。本を見ていてそう思います。彼の主張に穴はたくさんあるということです。じゃあ彼の言うことは全て信じないべきか、というところから出発しています。
通州事件の写真が南京のに使われているという有名な女の人の腑分けの写真ですね。今回東中野教授の本には用いられていないようなので、私も取り上げません。その写真についても本当は検証したいところなんですけどね。

 
At 7/16/2006 07:47:00 AM , Blogger wally4media said...

I have read comments in both Japanese and English. *sigh* The problem with the Japanese "revisionist" professors, the "apologists," and all their fans, the small minority, is that when they keep publishing all of their books about this number, that number, this picture, that picture, they COMPLETELY fail to answer one, simple question:

Why wsa the Imperial Japanese Army in Nanjing in 1938? How did they get there? Why were they there?

Did they go there for a short vacation, a weekend trip, and there was some lie about a massacre, and so they just got on a boat and left?

Be real people. Nanjing was just one stop on a horrible war with many incidents that started in 1931, then 1937 to 1945.

From the diary of Ishigari Itaro, Japan Foreign Ministry's East Asian Bureau Chief, at the time of the Nanjing incident:

"A leter arrived from our army in Nanking. It describes an horrendous situatin of pillage and rape. My god, is this how our imperial army behaves?"

From the diary of reserve general Mazaki Jinzaburo, Jan. 28, 1938, after speaking with fellow reserve general Eto Genkuro about the Nanjing incident:

"Military order and discipline have collapsed... It is almost unbearable to hear the stories of robbery, rape, and pillaging."

If these two men, at the time, who had access to information, refused to believe lies, why can't people do so now? These are just two of many examples.

I am an American. I see the same tragedy in Iraq. Real patriotism is not blind patriotism.

 
At 12/09/2006 11:07:00 PM , Blogger yellowpeep said...

wally4media,
I didn't notice your comment. Sorry.

You wrote:
"Be real people. Nanjing was just one stop on a horrible war with many incidents that started in 1931, then 1937 to 1945."

Yeah, I completely agree to it. There occurred nasty incidents already prior to Sino-Japanese war. We have to trace it back at least to 1900 or more. It's very wrong if we think Japan suddently invaded China and killed a lot of civillians. History is not that simple. Iraq war is already complex and hard to discuss it from just one point of view.

 
At 12/16/2006 08:28:00 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

You know, China released new and correctly revised book of 爱新觉罗溥仪(aixinjiaoluo puyi).

It was whiteerased in 1960's. But this one is more correct.
Please read.

http://www.china.com.cn/book/txt/2006-12/11/content_7487836.htm
http://i99.photobucket.com/albums/l291/jayoosan/book.jpg

http://www.asahi.com/international/update/1217/001.html

 
At 4/18/2007 02:09:00 AM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

interesting topic.

maybe you should represent if you would like to discuss according to FACTS academically proved or just according to what some people say and your imagination. If it is blurred, you will always get various responses which will never settle.

 
At 12/20/2010 08:07:00 AM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

南京事件は事実であり、虐殺などの罪行も大量な戦争日記にも書かれていた。
Japan Shame on you!

 
At 5/28/2014 04:20:00 PM , Blogger Mitsuo Matsuyama said...

To be honest, I didnt get what you wanna say. You show pictures that is real and yet you are trying to say that is not real. China should be ashamed for creating stories.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home